Matter of L. Ramirez: No Presumption for U Visa Continuances

The BIA ruled that noncitizens with pending U visa petitions are no longer presumptively entitled to continuances, directing Immigration Judges instead to apply a balancing test weighing good cause and visa availability.
Matter of L. Ramirez: No Presumption for U Visa Continuances

Table of Contents

▼

    Introduction

    The Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) issued a published precedent decision, Matter of L. Ramirez, 30 I&N Dec. 157 (BIA 2026), decided October 16, 2026. This BIA U visa continuance decision covers a key question. Is a noncitizen who has filed a prima facie approvable U visa petition entitled to a presumption in favor of a continuance, meaning a delay of removal proceedings? The decision matters because the Board ended its earlier presumption. The Board also set out the test Immigration Judges use. That standard covers continuance requests resting on a pending visa petition or future visa availability.

    Case at a Glance

    • Citation: Matter of L. Ramirez, 30 I&N Dec. 157 (BIA 2026), Interim Decision #4260
    • Decision date: October 16, 2026
    • Issuing body: Board of Immigration Appeals
    • Panel or author: Chief Appellate Immigration Judge Malphrus, writing for a panel that also included Appellate Immigration Judges Chaban and Volkert
    • Disposition: Appeal dismissed
    • Subject: Continuances in removal proceedings based on a pending U visa petition or future visa availability

    Facts and Procedural History in Matter of L. Ramirez

    The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) began removal proceedings against the respondent in June 2017. On September 26, 2017, the respondent filed a petition for a nonimmigrant visa under section 101(a)(15)(U) of the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA), 8 U.S.C. § 1101(a)(15)(U) (2012). This visa is known as a U visa. He filed it with United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS), together with an application for a waiver of inadmissibility. The petition claimed that an armed robbery victimized him in February 2016.

    The respondent appeared before the Immigration Judge for his initial hearing on October 23, 2018. Through counsel, he admitted removability and asked for a continuance to prepare. The Immigration Judge granted it and set the next hearing for January 24, 2019. That hearing was later reset to August 8, 2019.

    At the August 2019 hearing, the respondent asked for another continuance to wait for USCIS to adjudicate his U visa petition. The Immigration Judge allowed it over DHS’s opposition and set the next hearing for January 7, 2020. The Immigration Judge said he could not put off the case without end. He would not likely grant further continuances to await a USCIS decision.

    The petition remained pending at the January 2020 hearing. At that hearing, the respondent asked for another continuance, which DHS opposed. The Immigration Judge denied the request and ordered the respondent removed. On appeal, the Board noted that he has not provided any evidence that USCIS has adjudicated the petition.

    Under 8 C.F.R. § 1003.29 (2020), an Immigration Judge may grant a motion for continuance for good cause shown. The Board noted that the respondent bears the burden of establishing good cause. It cited Matter of L-A-B-R-, 27 I&N Dec. 405, 415 (A.G. 2018). The Board reviews de novo, meaning without deference, the legal question whether an Immigration Judge erred in granting a continuance. It cited Matter of J-A-F-S-, 29 I&N Dec. 195, 198 (BIA 2025), and 8 C.F.R. § 1003.1(d)(3)(ii) (2026).

    A collateral matter is one pending before another authority. When a continuance rests on one, Matter of L-A-B-R- directs the Immigration Judge to focus principally on two factors. The first is the likelihood that the noncitizen will receive the collateral relief. The second is whether that relief will materially affect the outcome of the removal proceedings.

    Immigration Judges also weigh secondary factors: whether the noncitizen used reasonable care in seeking the relief, DHS’s position on the motion, the length of the requested continuance, and the procedural history. The Board cited Matter of L-N-Y-, 27 I&N Dec. 755, 758 (BIA 2020). It noted that the two primary factors are not dispositive when relevant secondary factors weigh against continuing the proceedings.

    The respondent relied on Matter of Sanchez Sosa, 25 I&N Dec. 807 (BIA 2012). There the Board held, in the U visa context, a general rule. A rebuttable presumption exists that a noncitizen who has filed a prima facie approvable application with USCIS warrants a favorable exercise of discretion for a continuance for a reasonable period of time.

    Issues Presented in Matter of L. Ramirez

    The Board considered three questions. First, did the respondent show good cause for a further continuance to await USCIS’s adjudication of his U visa petition? Second, does a presumption in favor of a continuance apply to noncitizens with a prima facie approvable U visa petition, as Matter of Sanchez Sosa had held? Third, what standard governs continuance requests based on a pending visa petition or future visa availability?

    The Board’s Holding in Matter of L. Ramirez

    The Board announced three rules. First, there is no presumption in favor of a continuance for noncitizens who have filed a prima facie approvable U visa petition with USCIS. The Board added that one standard applies to every type of visa. It governs a continuance to await a visa petition’s adjudication or a visa’s availability. No special rule exists for U visas or any other nonpreference category of visa.

    Second, Immigration Judges should apply the balancing test from Matter of L-A-B-R- when deciding whether good cause exists for a continuance. This applies to continuances based on a pending visa petition or future visa availability. Judges should keep in mind the importance of the secondary factors. Good cause does not exist if visa availability is remote.

    Third, the Board reaffirmed that the law does not entitle noncitizens to delay completion of their removal proceedings pending availability of a visa.

    Applying these rules to “the record before us,” the Board concluded that the respondent did not meet his burden to show good cause and that the Immigration Judge properly denied the further continuance.

    Disposition

    The Board turned down the appeal. Its order also carried the Board’s standard notice. The notice covered civil monetary penalties for willful failure to depart under a final removal order and criminal penalties for certain reentry after removal, citing INA § 274D (2024), 8 U.S.C. § 1324d, and INA § 276(a), 8 U.S.C. § 1326(a) (2024).

    Effect of Matter of L. Ramirez on Existing Precedent

    The Board overruled the continuance standard in Matter of Sanchez Sosa, 25 I&N Dec. 807 (BIA 2012). The Board reaffirmed Matter of Quintero, 18 I&N Dec. 348 (BIA 1982), on one point: the law does not entitle noncitizens to delay completion of removal proceedings pending availability of a visa. It also applied the balancing test of Matter of L-A-B-R-, 27 I&N Dec. 405 (A.G. 2018).

    In Plain Terms

    Filing a U visa petition that looks approvable does not automatically favor a delay of removal proceedings. The Immigration Judge weighs several factors, including how long the delay would last, how careful the person has been, and what DHS says. A person also has no entitlement to hold up removal proceedings until a visa becomes available.

    The Board’s Rationale in Matter of L. Ramirez

    The Board began with the good cause requirement and the factors in Matter of L-A-B-R-. It recognized that the primary factors favored the respondent. He appeared prima facie eligible for a U visa and an inadmissibility waiver. USCIS approval would materially affect the outcome because he would no longer face removal as charged. Even so, the Board concluded that, on this record, the secondary factors strongly supported the Immigration Judge’s decision.

    The Board identified the length of the asked-for continuance as the most important secondary factor. The respondent gave no timeframe before the Immigration Judge in January 2020 or on appeal, so his request was, in the words of Matter of L-N-Y-, 27 I&N Dec. at 759, “for an unknown and potentially lengthy period of time.” The Board found that the case history showed the open-ended nature of the request. When the Immigration Judge denied the last continuance, the petition had been pending for over a year. More than 6 years later, the respondent still had not presented evidence of adjudication.

    The Board then turned to the respondent’s reliance on Matter of Sanchez Sosa. It said that the decision came before Matter of L-A-B-R- and did not consider visa availability in its good cause analysis. That omission, the Board said, is inconsistent with the Attorney General’s directive that visa availability is a relevant factor. The Board noted that Matter of L-A-B-R- made clear that good cause does not exist when visa availability is too remote.

    The Board also found that a presumption in favor of a continuance, applied when visa wait time is lengthy or indeterminate, is inconsistent with Matter of Quintero. It added that Matter of Sanchez Sosa did not address that conflict.

    Changed Circumstances and Public Interest

    The Board next addressed changed circumstances. Citing Matter of Ibarra-Vega, 29 I&N Dec. 476, 478–79 (BIA 2026), it explained that when the Board decided Matter of Sanchez Sosa there was a reasonable expectation that USCIS would generally adjudicate pending U visa requests within approximately 1 year. The Board said a yearly legal cap on U visas and excessive demand mean eligible petitioners now wait many years. Some wait decades. In a footnote, the Board reiterated that these wait times do not result from any action or inaction by USCIS. They result from demand exceeding the supply Congress authorized.

    The Board further found that a presumption also clashes with the public interest in bringing litigation to a close promptly, citing INS v. Abudu, 485 U.S. 94, 107 (1988).

    Finally, the Board found that the other secondary factors also weighed against a continuance. On diligence, the petition alleges that the qualifying crime occurred in February 2016. The respondent has not explained why he waited a year and a half to file it. On DHS’s position, the Board cited Matter of Pinzon Rozo, 29 I&N Dec. 507, 510 (BIA 2026), for the point that DHS’s opposition based on its interest in prompt resolution is an important consideration. It observed that the respondent had conceded removability and was not seeking any form of relief from removal before the Immigration Judge. Extending the proceedings with no end date over DHS’s opposition, it said, would significantly undermine the public interest in expeditious enforcement of the immigration laws.

    Practical Implications of the BIA U Visa Continuance Decision

    Published BIA decisions bind Immigration Judges and DHS officers unless later modified, overruled, or superseded. They do not bind federal courts. The federal courts of appeals may review decisions of the Board in removal cases.

    For Noncitizens and Their Families

    A pending U visa petition does not carry a presumption in favor of a continuance. The same balancing test may govern a request to wait for USCIS as governs a request tied to any other visa petition. People in removal proceedings with a pending petition may want to consider that the Board treated the length of the requested continuance as the most significant secondary factor in this case, and that the respondent offered no timeframe.

    The Board also looked at the timing of the petition’s filing relative to the underlying events, at whether the respondent explained any delay, and at DHS’s position. Evidence on those points, and on how long a wait for adjudication or visa availability may be, may be relevant. The Board ties its reasoning to the record before it, and each person’s circumstances differ.

    For Practitioners

    Practitioners may want to stop relying on Matter of Sanchez Sosa for a presumption and instead frame continuance motions around the Matter of L-A-B-R- factors. The Board stressed that favorable primary factors are not dispositive when secondary factors weigh against continuing.

    Speaking to each secondary factor directly may better support motions. Those factors are a proposed length of continuance, the reasons for any filing delay, the procedural history, and DHS’s position. Because the Board said good cause does not exist if visa availability is remote, information about visa availability may also be relevant.

    The Board stated that the same standard applies to any type of visa. The analysis may extend to other visa petitions and to continuance requests based on future visa availability.

    How Immigration Professional Association Can Help

    When removal proceedings and a pending visa petition overlap, the timing of hearings can shape a person’s options. At Immigration Professional Association, we represent clients in removal proceedings. Our work includes evaluating those options, preparing continuance motions and the supporting record, and appearing before Immigration Judges. We also assist clients on appeals to the Board.

    If you or a family member is in removal proceedings with a petition pending before USCIS, or a continuance request is under consideration, Immigration Professional Association can review the facts and discuss how the Board’s decision in Matter of L. Ramirez may bear on your situation. Please contact our office to schedule a consultation.

    This article is general information, not legal advice, and outcomes depend on the facts of each case.

    Was this information helpful? Please Share:

    Facebook
    LinkedIn
    X
    Reddit
    Print
    Email

    SEND A MESSAGE

    Ask Immigration Lawyer

    Tags
    Copyright Disclosure